CCompound

Indexy a trhy

How Equity Indices Are Created and Updated

5 min readCompound

Key takeaways

An equity index is not just a list of companies — it is a precisely defined methodology with specific rules for inclusion, exclusion, weighting, and rebalancing, decided by an index committee.

Who decides on index composition?

Every index has its own administrator. The S&P 500 is administered by S&P Global; MSCI administers its own family of indices (MSCI World, Emerging Markets, etc.); FTSE Russell administers the Russell 2000 and FTSE All World. Each administrator has a methodology document — a publicly available document that precisely describes the criteria for inclusion and exclusion.

S&P 500 criteria (simplified):

Why does addition to an index change the price?

When the S&P 500 announces the addition of a new company, hundreds of passive ETFs and funds must buy that stock immediately — otherwise their portfolio would not track the index. This concentrated demand has historically caused a short-term rise in the added stock's price of several percent on the announcement day. The effect is called the index effect and is why a major addition to an index (Tesla in 2020, Nvidia at various index version updates) can move the market.

Implication for passive investors: You buy "after" the company is added to the index — you pay a price that already includes this short-term rise. It is a cost of passive investing, but still far lower than the costs of active stock picking.

How does rebalancing work?

MSCI rebalances its indices four times a year (in February, May, August, and November). The S&P 500 rebalances quarterly and also on an extraordinary basis for mergers and bankruptcies. At each rebalance all ETFs tracking the index must adjust their portfolio composition — this causes elevated trading volumes on rebalance days. Read more about how ETFs work in the article what is an ETF or in the ETF section.

FAQ

Can a company apply to be included in the S&P 500?

No — a company cannot actively apply. The S&P Global index committee monitors the market and companies that meet all criteria (market cap, profitability, free float, liquidity) become candidates. The final decision rests with the committee, which also weighs qualitative factors.

What happens when a company drops out of the index?

Passive ETFs tracking the index must sell the stock immediately after the rebalance. This can cause a short-term decline in the removed company's share price. For the company itself it is largely a symbolic event — it does not affect its business operations, but it may make it harder to raise capital and reduce institutional interest.

Are indices neutral?

Indices are defined by methodologies and the decisions of specific committees — they are not purely mechanical. For example Tesla waited longer for S&P 500 inclusion than its market cap would suggest. The four-quarters-of-profitability criterion held it back. Methodologies therefore have implicit values — profitability is prized in the S&P 500.

Open in the app with tools →